Your Brooder Stinks. That’s How You Know It’s Working.
⚠️ Disclosure: This post contains affiliate links. If you purchase through my links I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. I only recommend products I personally use and believe in.
Your brooder stinks. Because chickens are gross. And if you’re like me your gross little chickens are being gross in your living room right now, because we didn’t get gross little poop machines to passively wonder how they’re doing from afar and if their fragile little bodies will survive the night — we got them to make sure they turn into gross healthy adults that will poop all over our decks and ruin our garden beds and hopefully pay their rent with healthy eggs and bodies that we can’t get at the grocery store, am I right?
That last part was a joke. Of course we can get all of that at the grocery store. And we all know our disgusting little backyard buddies are even more expensive and stress-inducing than store bought anything, but at least we can control something in our increasingly out of control world where we have far more to worry about than how disgusting our living room smells when our gross little chickens are eating their own poop in front of company we feel comfortable enough to have over in our delicate time of questionable home hygiene. Because only we — those brave and dedicated enough to actually raise these disgusting little dinosaurs — know just how very unlike a Disney movie they truly are.
The problem is that they’re not just gross, they’re delicate. You have to tend to their sensitive little bellies and systems in very specific ways. They bathe in dirt and eat each other’s poop but we’re the ones who have to be careful. Especially when they’re young and ultra fragile and excessively expensive if you’re brand new to the game. You need this specific water bowl, you need this specific feed, you can’t use these chemicals but you can and maybe should use these chemicals. They need this much space but also this much heat and goodness if it’s too hot or there’s an unsafe heating element that burns the whole thing down. Do you want medicated feed or vaccination? Do you get your little monsters from a breeder or from Tractor Supply? And are you actually allowed to clean the brooder, or do you have to chuck the whole thing — poop and all — every time you want to be a respectable adult in society?
Here’s what nobody tells you when you’re three hours deep into backyard chicken forums at midnight: most of it is noise. The list of things that will actually kill your chicks is short. The list of things that actually matter is also short. Everything else is the internet being the internet.
I currently have 20 chicks in a 6×5 child’s camping tent in my living room. We’re on day 12. We’ve lost exactly one — our poor girl who got trampled under the heat plate — and the rest are flying around and roosting and being generally chaotic and alive. Here’s what actually kept them that way.
Keep them where you can actually see them.
I know the garage seems appealing when you’re staring at a tent full of wood shavings in your living room. Resist. The first two weeks especially, you want eyes on these things. Not obsessive, panicked eyes — just the casual “I’m walking by and I can see they’re all upright and breathing” kind of eyes. That’s worth more than any gadget on the market.
Check their butts once a day.
I know. I know. But pasty butt is real and it will kill them and it is exactly what it sounds like — their vents get clogged and they can’t go and then they die. We had to clean several in the first few days. Warm water, gentle pressure, done. Just check. It takes thirty seconds and it matters.
Get a heat plate. Not a heat lamp.
I was already a heat plate convert from our big girl coop where we use one when temperatures drop below 20 degrees in winter. When it was time to set up the brooder the choice was obvious. I’m not nervous about a heat lamp in general — but in a tent with no good way to secure it and keep it from falling? Absolutely not. Heat plates sit flat, they don’t start fires, and the chicks regulate their own temperature by going under or coming out, which is much closer to how a mama hen actually works anyway.
I’ll also say this — some heat plates are designed with domes specifically to keep chicks from walking on top of them and I genuinely don’t understand the logic. Mine walk on top of it constantly. They roost up there. They explore. They have opinions about the best spot. Why would I take that away from them? The dome plates feel weird to me. A flat plate on some bricks works perfectly well and gives them more enrichment not less.
🔗 What I actually use: The 16×16 heat plate from Hatching Time — flat, no fire risk, chicks love roosting on top. Shop it here →
Speaking of bricks — use them.
We set the heat plate on bricks and stack more as they grow to keep the height right. It’s free, it’s adjustable, and it works. The space under the plate matters too — make sure there’s enough room for everyone to get under there without piling on top of each other. That’s how we lost our girl. She didn’t have enough space to get out from under the crowd. More space under the plate is always better.
Get a Bluetooth thermometer.
There are actual best practices for brooder temperature as chicks age — starting around 95 degrees the first week and dropping roughly five degrees each week after. You cannot eyeball this reliably and you cannot be standing over them with a thermometer every hour. A cheap Bluetooth thermometer lets you check from the couch, from bed, from wherever. Worth every penny for the sleep alone.
That’s it. That’s the list. Everything else — the special waterer inserts and the organic grit supplements and the elaborate brooder builds you’re seeing on Pinterest — that stuff is fine if you want it. But it’s not what keeps them alive. What keeps them alive is warmth, space, clean water, clean vents, and a human nearby who actually gives a damn.
Your brooder smells because they’re in there doing their disgusting little best. That’s the whole point.
Show me your brooder setup in the comments. Bonus points for creative repurposing of things that were definitely not designed for chickens.